oficina / memoria Public

Spec §8.8, draft 3: drop the facts table; fix the label rule again

Second review by Fable 5.1 (dispatched: fable; self-reported:
claude-fable-5-1). REQUEST CHANGES on draft 2 and on the plan, fifteen
must-fix. It confirmed the cap contradiction the plan found, from the
other side: any LIMIT on a pre-ruling facts query lets a withheld
document eat a slot, so "count after the ruling" becomes unimplementable.

So draft 3 extracts once, at query time, over the ruled results. No
index change, no stored state, no migration, no new seal purpose. The
reachability limit goes back to §12 where draft 1 had it, and the IDF
measurement stays as the reason §12's eventual fix is not "index the
kind words" — with draft 2's overclaim corrected: on the NEAR comment's
own fixture the injection changes nothing, because that chunk already
says "phone". The exposure is a corpus where many chunks carry numbers
and few say the word.

The label rule broke four more ways, all found by running it by hand
rather than by reasoning about it. A markdown bullet yields a run of "-",
which "ends in a separator" and gives an empty label — two bullets then
collide and a plain contact list never boxes. "Phone: 01 547 7854 - 01
598 1234" labels the second number with the first one's value. A
sentence boundary placed too late yields "Smith's direct line" from "Dr.
Smith's direct line:" — a label the document did not write, from the rule
whose whole justification is that it never composes, and draft 2 claimed
that direction was safe. And the over-cap fallback silently replaced a
document's warning with a vaguer trail; it now renders no box for that
kind rather than substituting.

Cap and collision are per kind, collision is keyed on the whole citation
line rather than the label alone, and a box row carries title and trail
like a result row.

Gate 34 named a sibling stub that does not exist — twice, in the section
that cites §10's renamed-test rule. fixedCustody rules every candidate
from one field and cannot express its fixtures. It moves to
internal/memoria against a fake that rules per item id, and gains the
two fixtures that can see a cross-wired citation and a collision counted
before the ruling. Gate 38 is struck rather than written: it could not
have gone red.

Also: the Passages comment was cited for the inverse of its lesson;
decision 10's narrowing is now filed NEEDS PAUL beside decision 15's; §13
regained the closing sentence a sub-bullet had swallowed; and whether the
cap makes the box inert on the live corpus is recorded as owed
measurement.

NOTES.md was swept into draft 2 by a careless `git add -A` and is
untracked again.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>