eleven / ocho Public

web+native: reply threads group on the root message — replying to a reply continues the thread (#430)

Replies now form iMessage-style threads keyed on the TOP message. Replying
to any message in a thread stages the root's {id,name,snippet} (web
replyTarget in chat.js; native ChatFeedModel.replyTarget, used by both
platforms' startReply), and the "N Replies" tally groups on the resolved
root — legacy chains (a reply quoting another reply) resolve transitively
through the loaded window on both sides.

Contract pinned by two new vectors in test/event-vectors/chat.json
(reply_in_thread_targets_root, reply_thread_grouping), tested against the
real implementations on both sides (event-vectors.test.mjs now imports
chat.js's viewItems/replyTarget; ReplyThreadVectorTests.swift drives the
now-static ChatFeedModel.refreshReplyCounts). Also wires
event-vectors.test.mjs into npm test — it had never been added to the
script despite CLAUDE.md listing it.

No server changes: reply metadata stays inside the encrypted payload.
Groundwork for the thread view (PR 2: web overlay; PR 3: iOS/Mac).

Co-authored-by: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>

Paul Campbell 4 months ago bcdd505bff74ad23cd58d0b36aee6abd989a9a88 parent 6e86d2e

9 files changed, +326 −21

changelog/2026-07-08-reply-threads.md +4 −0
ios/LChat/Views/NativeChatScreen.swift +2 −1
ios/LChatCore/Sources/LChatCore/ChatFeedModel.swift +65 −14
ios/LChatCore/Tests/LChatCoreTests/ReplyThreadVectorTests.swift +101 −0
ios/LChatMac/NativeFeedView.swift +2 −1
package.json +1 −1
test/event-vectors.test.mjs +35 −0
test/event-vectors/chat.json +67 −0
web/static/apps/chat.js +49 −4

diff --git a/changelog/2026-07-08-reply-threads.md b/changelog/2026-07-08-reply-threads.md

new file mode 100644

index 0000000..29908b4

--- /dev/null

+++ b/changelog/2026-07-08-reply-threads.md

@@ -0,0 +1,4 @@

+🤖 Replies now stick to the conversation they started. Replying to a reply

+continues that thread — your message quotes the original message at the top of

+the thread, not the reply you tapped — and the "N Replies" count under the

+original message now includes the whole back-and-forth.

diff --git a/ios/LChat/Views/NativeChatScreen.swift b/ios/LChat/Views/NativeChatScreen.swift

index ea6cc21..ff820af 100644

--- a/ios/LChat/Views/NativeChatScreen.swift

+++ b/ios/LChat/Views/NativeChatScreen.swift

@@ -860,7 +860,8 @@ struct NativeChatScreen: View {

private func startReply(_ m: ChatFeedModel.Message) {

editingID = nil

- replyTo = ReplyRef(id: m.id, name: m.name, snippet: replySnippet(m.raw))

+ // Replying to a reply continues its thread: target the TOP message.

+ replyTo = model.replyTarget(for: m)

composerFocused = true

}

diff --git a/ios/LChatCore/Sources/LChatCore/ChatFeedModel.swift b/ios/LChatCore/Sources/LChatCore/ChatFeedModel.swift

index 5c986f5..7142f5f 100644

--- a/ios/LChatCore/Sources/LChatCore/ChatFeedModel.swift

+++ b/ios/LChatCore/Sources/LChatCore/ChatFeedModel.swift

@@ -23,10 +23,14 @@ public final class ChatFeedModel: ObservableObject {

public var attachments: [Attachment] = []

public var reply: ReplyRef? // set when this message quotes another

public var reactions: [Reaction] = []

- // Folded from the other direction: how many messages quote THIS one,

- // and where the thread of replies starts (the web's "N Replies" tag).

+ // Folded from the other direction: how many messages are in the reply

+ // thread THIS message tops, and where that thread starts (the web's

+ // "N Replies" tag). Tallies group on the resolved ROOT message.

public var replyCount: Int = 0

public var firstReplyID: Int64?

+ // For a reply: the resolved sid of its thread's TOP message (the web's

+ // `replyRoot`) — one hop for new replies, chased for legacy chains.

+ public var threadRootID: Int64?

// The decrypted payload as sent — an edit re-encrypts {…raw, text}, so

// attachments/reply metadata survive the rewrite (chat.js does the same).

public var raw = MessagePayload()

@@ -672,7 +676,7 @@ public final class ChatFeedModel: ObservableObject {

// Map a stored (already-decrypted) page into view messages and publish.

private func publishStored(_ stored: [MessageStore.StoredMessage]) {

var list: [Message] = stored.compactMap(viewMessage)

- refreshReplyCounts(&list)

+ Self.refreshReplyCounts(&list)

messages = list

}

@@ -708,7 +712,7 @@ public final class ChatFeedModel: ObservableObject {

}

guard changed else { return }

list.sort { $0.id < $1.id }

- refreshReplyCounts(&list)

+ Self.refreshReplyCounts(&list)

messages = list

}

@@ -755,7 +759,7 @@ public final class ChatFeedModel: ObservableObject {

}

list.sort { $0.id < $1.id }

- refreshReplyCounts(&list)

+ Self.refreshReplyCounts(&list)

messages = list

}

@@ -816,7 +820,7 @@ public final class ChatFeedModel: ObservableObject {

guard let id = frame.id else { return }

var list = messages

list.removeAll { $0.id == id }

- refreshReplyCounts(&list)

+ Self.refreshReplyCounts(&list)

// The implosion: rows carry a scale+fade removal transition, and

// deletes are the one mutation that publishes inside an animation

// (arrivals/prepends stay unanimated by design).

@@ -944,7 +948,7 @@ public final class ChatFeedModel: ObservableObject {

var list = messages

fold(id: id, at: at, payload: payload,

edited: edited, reactions: reactions, into: &list)

- refreshReplyCounts(&list)

+ Self.refreshReplyCounts(&list)

messages = list

if let payload {

storeMirror(.init(id: id, at: at, edited: edited,

@@ -1010,20 +1014,67 @@ public final class ChatFeedModel: ObservableObject {

}

- // Re-derive each message's reply tally (chat.js's replyCounts fold): a

- // quote names its parent, so count inbound quotes per id. Runs once per

- // batch, before the list publishes.

- private func refreshReplyCounts(_ list: inout [Message]) {

+ // Resolve every reply's thread ROOT (message id → root id). New replies

+ // point straight at the top message, so this is one hop; legacy chains (a

+ // reply quoting another reply) are chased through the loaded window,

+ // stopping at the deepest pointer we can see. Hop-capped so a hostile

+ // payload can't cycle forever. Mirrors chat.js's rootRef — pinned by the

+ // reply_thread_grouping vector (test/event-vectors/chat.json).

+ nonisolated static func threadRoots(_ list: [Message]) -> [Int64: Int64] {

+ var byID: [Int64: Message] = [:]

+ for m in list { byID[m.id] = m }

+ var roots: [Int64: Int64] = [:]

+ for m in list {

+ guard var ref = m.reply, let refID = ref.id, refID > 0 else { continue }

+ var hops = 0

+ while hops < 100, let id = ref.id,

+ let parent = byID[id], let up = parent.reply, (up.id ?? 0) > 0 {

+ ref = up

+ hops += 1

+ }

+ if let rootID = ref.id { roots[m.id] = rootID }

+ }

+ return roots

+ }

+ /// The ReplyRef a reply to `m` should carry: replying to any message in a

+ /// thread continues that thread, so the ref always names the thread's TOP

+ /// message — never the tapped reply. When the root is loaded its

+ /// name/snippet are snapshotted fresh; an unloaded root falls back to the

+ /// deepest quoted ref we can see. Mirrors chat.js's replyTarget.

+ nonisolated static func replyTarget(in list: [Message], for m: Message) -> ReplyRef {

+ guard let reply = m.reply, (reply.id ?? 0) > 0 else {

+ return ReplyRef(id: m.id, name: m.name, snippet: replySnippet(m.raw))

+ }

+ let rootID = threadRoots(list)[m.id] ?? reply.id

+ if let id = rootID, let root = list.first(where: { $0.id == id }) {

+ return ReplyRef(id: root.id, name: root.name, snippet: replySnippet(root.raw))

+ }

+ return ReplyRef(id: rootID, name: reply.name, snippet: reply.snippet)

+ }

+ /// Composer entry point for both platforms' startReply.

+ public func replyTarget(for m: Message) -> ReplyRef {

+ Self.replyTarget(in: messages, for: m)

+ }

+ // Re-derive each message's reply-thread tally (chat.js's replyCounts fold):

+ // every reply counts toward its resolved ROOT, so a legacy chain tallies on

+ // the thread's top message. Runs once per batch, before the list publishes.

+ // Static so the reply_thread_grouping vector test can drive it directly.

+ nonisolated static func refreshReplyCounts(_ list: inout [Message]) {

+ let roots = Self.threadRoots(list)

var counts: [Int64: Int] = [:]

var first: [Int64: Int64] = [:]

for m in list {

- guard let parent = m.reply?.id, parent > 0 else { continue }

- counts[parent, default: 0] += 1

- if first[parent] == nil { first[parent] = m.id }

+ guard let root = roots[m.id], root > 0 else { continue }

+ counts[root, default: 0] += 1

+ if first[root] == nil { first[root] = m.id }

}

for i in list.indices {

list[i].replyCount = counts[list[i].id] ?? 0

list[i].firstReplyID = first[list[i].id]

+ list[i].threadRootID = roots[list[i].id]

}

diff --git a/ios/LChatCore/Tests/LChatCoreTests/ReplyThreadVectorTests.swift b/ios/LChatCore/Tests/LChatCoreTests/ReplyThreadVectorTests.swift

new file mode 100644

index 0000000..42cebc6

--- /dev/null

+++ b/ios/LChatCore/Tests/LChatCoreTests/ReplyThreadVectorTests.swift

@@ -0,0 +1,101 @@

+import XCTest

+@testable import LChatCore

+// 🤖 Cross-platform contract tests for reply-thread grouping — the native side

+// of test/event-vectors/chat.json's `reply_thread_grouping` +

+// `reply_in_thread_targets_root` vectors (web twin: test/event-vectors.test.mjs

+// against chat.js's viewItems/replyTarget).

+//

+// The contract: reply threads group on the resolved ROOT message. New replies

+// point straight at the root; a legacy chain (a reply quoting another reply)

+// resolves transitively through loaded messages. Replying to ANY message in a

+// thread stages the root — never the tapped reply.

+final class ReplyThreadVectorTests: XCTestCase {

+ typealias Message = ChatFeedModel.Message

+ // The reply_thread_grouping vector's message_sequence, folded.

+ private func vectorMessages() -> [Message] {

+ let alice = MessagePayload(type: nil, uid: "user-alice-1", name: "Alice",

+ text: "Hello everyone", ts: 1_700_000_000_000,

+ action: nil, attachments: nil, replyTo: nil)

+ return [

+ Message(id: 100, name: "Alice", text: "Hello everyone", mine: false,

+ at: 1_700_000_000, edited: false, raw: alice),

+ Message(id: 101, name: "Bob", text: "Hi Alice", mine: false,

+ at: 1_700_000_001, edited: false,

+ reply: ReplyRef(id: 100, name: "Alice", snippet: "Hello everyone")),

+ // Legacy chain: quotes reply 101, not the root — must still resolve to 100.

+ Message(id: 102, name: "Charlie", text: "Welcome!", mine: false,

+ at: 1_700_000_002, edited: false,

+ reply: ReplyRef(id: 101, name: "Bob", snippet: "Hi Alice")),

+ Message(id: 103, name: "Dana", text: "Good to be here", mine: false,

+ at: 1_700_000_003, edited: false,

+ reply: ReplyRef(id: 100, name: "Alice", snippet: "Hello everyone")),

+ ]

+ }

+ func testThreadGrouping() {

+ var list = vectorMessages()

+ ChatFeedModel.refreshReplyCounts(&list)

+ // expected_threads.roots: every reply resolves to root 100.

+ XCTAssertEqual(list.first { $0.id == 101 }?.threadRootID, 100)

+ XCTAssertEqual(list.first { $0.id == 102 }?.threadRootID, 100, "legacy chain resolves transitively")

+ XCTAssertEqual(list.first { $0.id == 103 }?.threadRootID, 100)

+ XCTAssertNil(list.first { $0.id == 100 }?.threadRootID, "the root is not itself a reply")

+ // expected_threads.reply_counts + first_reply.

+ XCTAssertEqual(list.first { $0.id == 100 }?.replyCount, 3, "the root tallies its whole thread")

+ XCTAssertEqual(list.first { $0.id == 100 }?.firstReplyID, 101)

+ XCTAssertEqual(list.first { $0.id == 101 }?.replyCount, 0, "a mid-thread reply never tallies")

+ }

+ func testReplyTargetStagesRoot() {

+ let list = vectorMessages()

+ // expected_reply_target: replying to the legacy chain reply 102 stages the

+ // root's id with a fresh snapshot of the root's name/text.

+ let target = ChatFeedModel.replyTarget(in: list, for: list.first { $0.id == 102 }!)

+ XCTAssertEqual(target.id, 100)

+ XCTAssertEqual(target.name, "Alice")

+ XCTAssertEqual(target.snippet, "Hello everyone")

+ // Replying to a direct reply also stages the root.

+ let fromDirect = ChatFeedModel.replyTarget(in: list, for: list.first { $0.id == 103 }!)

+ XCTAssertEqual(fromDirect.id, 100)

+ // Replying to a non-reply targets that message itself (it becomes the root).

+ let fresh = ChatFeedModel.replyTarget(in: list, for: list.first { $0.id == 100 }!)

+ XCTAssertEqual(fresh.id, 100)

+ XCTAssertEqual(fresh.name, "Alice")

+ XCTAssertEqual(fresh.snippet, "Hello everyone")

+ }

+ func testUnloadedRootFallsBackToQuotedRef() {

+ // The parent scrolled out of the loaded window: keep the deepest pointer we

+ // can see (the quoted ref's frozen snapshot) rather than inventing one.

+ let orphan = Message(id: 200, name: "Eve", text: "Late reply", mine: false,

+ at: 1_700_000_010, edited: false,

+ reply: ReplyRef(id: 42, name: "Old Root", snippet: "long ago"))

+ var list = [orphan]

+ ChatFeedModel.refreshReplyCounts(&list)

+ XCTAssertEqual(list[0].threadRootID, 42, "an unloaded parent is still the best-known root")

+ let target = ChatFeedModel.replyTarget(in: list, for: list[0])

+ XCTAssertEqual(target.id, 42)

+ XCTAssertEqual(target.name, "Old Root")

+ XCTAssertEqual(target.snippet, "long ago")

+ }

+ func testReplyCycleIsHopCapped() {

+ // A hostile payload could quote in a cycle — the walk must terminate.

+ var list = [

+ Message(id: 1, name: "A", text: "a", mine: false, at: 1, edited: false,

+ reply: ReplyRef(id: 2, name: "B", snippet: "b")),

+ Message(id: 2, name: "B", text: "b", mine: false, at: 2, edited: false,

+ reply: ReplyRef(id: 1, name: "A", snippet: "a")),

+ ]

+ ChatFeedModel.refreshReplyCounts(&list) // must not hang

+ XCTAssertNotNil(list[0].threadRootID)

+ }

diff --git a/ios/LChatMac/NativeFeedView.swift b/ios/LChatMac/NativeFeedView.swift

index 0b214cf..3d43cc3 100644

--- a/ios/LChatMac/NativeFeedView.swift

+++ b/ios/LChatMac/NativeFeedView.swift

@@ -1016,7 +1016,8 @@ struct NativeFeedView: View {

private func startReply(_ m: ChatFeedModel.Message) {

editingID = nil

- replyTo = ReplyRef(id: m.id, name: m.name, snippet: replySnippet(m.raw))

+ // Replying to a reply continues its thread: target the TOP message.

+ replyTo = model.replyTarget(for: m)

composerFocused = true

}

diff --git a/package.json b/package.json

index be238b0..6fe6a5f 100644

--- a/package.json

+++ b/package.json

@@ -3,6 +3,6 @@

"private": true,

"type": "module",

"scripts": {

- "test": "node test/crypto.test.mjs && node test/ui.test.mjs && node test/format.test.mjs && node test/bootscene.test.mjs && node test/message.test.mjs && node test/threadkey.test.mjs && node test/messageblob.test.mjs && node test/blobbytes.test.mjs && node test/nativeblob.test.mjs && node test/apps.test.mjs && node test/flow.test.mjs && node test/tutorial.test.mjs && node test/actions.test.mjs && node test/commands.test.mjs && node test/context.test.mjs && node test/knowledge.test.mjs && node test/invite.test.mjs && node test/backup.test.mjs && node test/connect.test.mjs && node test/check-app.test.mjs && node test/sandbox.test.mjs && node test/sandbox-bridge.test.mjs && node home/test/crypto.test.mjs && node home/test/serverlist.test.mjs && node home/test/fader.test.mjs"

+ "test": "node test/crypto.test.mjs && node test/ui.test.mjs && node test/format.test.mjs && node test/bootscene.test.mjs && node test/message.test.mjs && node test/threadkey.test.mjs && node test/messageblob.test.mjs && node test/blobbytes.test.mjs && node test/nativeblob.test.mjs && node test/apps.test.mjs && node test/event-vectors.test.mjs && node test/flow.test.mjs && node test/tutorial.test.mjs && node test/actions.test.mjs && node test/commands.test.mjs && node test/context.test.mjs && node test/knowledge.test.mjs && node test/invite.test.mjs && node test/backup.test.mjs && node test/connect.test.mjs && node test/check-app.test.mjs && node test/sandbox.test.mjs && node test/sandbox-bridge.test.mjs && node home/test/crypto.test.mjs && node home/test/serverlist.test.mjs && node home/test/fader.test.mjs"

}

diff --git a/test/event-vectors.test.mjs b/test/event-vectors.test.mjs

index aa55267..83c5944 100644

--- a/test/event-vectors.test.mjs

+++ b/test/event-vectors.test.mjs

@@ -1,5 +1,9 @@

import assert from "assert";

import { allVectors } from "./event-vectors/index.js";

+// The reply-thread rollup is tested against the REAL implementation (chat.js

+// exports both as pure functions), not a reconstruction — grouping rules are

+// too easy to fork silently.

+import { viewItems, replyTarget } from "../web/static/apps/chat.js";

// Import chat.js fold handlers — the ones we're testing.

// The app.hostEvents from web/static/apps/chat.js.

@@ -180,6 +184,37 @@ allVectors.chat.forEach((vector) => {

});

}

+ // Reply-thread grouping vectors: fold the whole sequence, then assert the

+ // thread rollup (every reply resolves to its ROOT — legacy chains included)

+ // and the compose-side contract (replying anywhere in a thread stages the root).

+ if (vector.expected_threads) {

+ test(`chat threads: ${vector.name} — replies group on the resolved root`, () => {

+ let state = { msgs: [] };

+ for (const step of vector.message_sequence) {

+ const event = { type: "chat.msg", ...step.decrypted_payload };

+ const meta = { id: step.server_message.id, ts: step.server_message.created_at * 1000 };

+ state = testChatMsgFold(state, event, meta);

+ }

+ const items = viewItems(state.msgs);

+ const bySid = new Map(items.map((i) => [i.sid, i]));

+ for (const [sid, root] of Object.entries(vector.expected_threads.roots)) {

+ assert.strictEqual(bySid.get(Number(sid))?.replyRoot, root, `message ${sid} should resolve to root ${root}`);

+ }

+ for (const [root, count] of Object.entries(vector.expected_threads.reply_counts)) {

+ assert.strictEqual(bySid.get(Number(root))?.replyCount, count, `root ${root} should tally ${count} thread messages`);

+ }

+ for (const [root, first] of Object.entries(vector.expected_threads.first_reply)) {

+ const firstReply = items.find((i) => i.replyRoot === Number(root));

+ assert.strictEqual(firstReply && firstReply.sid, first, `first reply in root ${root}'s thread should be ${first}`);

+ }

+ const rt = vector.expected_reply_target;

+ if (rt) {

+ const m = state.msgs.find((x) => x.sid === rt.for_message);

+ assert.deepStrictEqual(replyTarget(state.msgs, m), rt.replyTo, "replyTarget should stage the thread's top message");

+ }

+ });

+ }

if (vector.expected_fold_event?.type === "chat.react") {

test(`chat.react: ${vector.name} — folds reactions correctly and produces expected event shape`, () => {

const state = { msgs: [{ sid: vector.server_reaction_frame.message_id, reactions: [] }] };

diff --git a/test/event-vectors/chat.json b/test/event-vectors/chat.json

index 61beb78..ff670b9 100644

--- a/test/event-vectors/chat.json

+++ b/test/event-vectors/chat.json

@@ -119,6 +119,73 @@

"attachments": []

}

+ {

+ "name": "reply_in_thread_targets_root",

+ "description": "Replying to a message that is itself a reply continues that thread: the composer stages the thread's TOP message, so the payload's replyTo carries the ROOT's id/name/snippet — never the tapped reply's.",

+ "note": "Compose-side contract (web replyTarget in chat.js; native ChatFeedModel.replyTarget). Here Dana replied to message 12347 (Charlie's reply), but the staged replyTo names root 12345. The fold treats it like any reply; grouping is pinned by reply_thread_grouping.",

+ "decrypted_payload": {

+ "name": "Dana",

+ "text": "Same here!",

+ "ts": 1700000004000,

+ "uid": "user-dana-1",

+ "replyTo": {

+ "id": 12345,

+ "name": "Alice",

+ "snippet": "Hello everyone"

+ }

+ },

+ "server_message": {

+ "id": 12349,

+ "created_at": 1700000004,

+ "blob": "encrypted(decrypted_payload)"

+ },

+ "expected_fold_event": {

+ "type": "chat.msg",

+ "name": "Dana",

+ "text": "Same here!",

+ "ts": 1700000004000,

+ "uid": "user-dana-1",

+ "replyTo": {

+ "id": 12345,

+ "name": "Alice",

+ "snippet": "Hello everyone"

+ },

+ "attachments": []

+ }

+ },

+ {

+ "name": "reply_thread_grouping",

+ "description": "Reply threads group on the resolved ROOT message: new replies point straight at the root; a legacy chain (a reply quoting another reply) resolves transitively through loaded messages. The root's tally counts every message in its thread, and the first reply is the tally's jump target.",

+ "note": "Multi-message vector: fold the sequence, then derive the thread rollup (web viewItems replyRoot/replyCount in chat.js; native ChatFeedModel.threadRoots/refreshReplyCounts). Message 102 is a LEGACY chain — it quotes reply 101, not the root — and must still resolve to root 100.",

+ "message_sequence": [

+ {

+ "server_message": { "id": 100, "created_at": 1700000000 },

+ "decrypted_payload": { "name": "Alice", "text": "Hello everyone", "ts": 1700000000000, "uid": "user-alice-1" }

+ },

+ {

+ "server_message": { "id": 101, "created_at": 1700000001 },

+ "decrypted_payload": { "name": "Bob", "text": "Hi Alice", "ts": 1700000001000, "uid": "user-bob-1", "replyTo": { "id": 100, "name": "Alice", "snippet": "Hello everyone" } }

+ },

+ {

+ "server_message": { "id": 102, "created_at": 1700000002 },

+ "decrypted_payload": { "name": "Charlie", "text": "Welcome!", "ts": 1700000002000, "uid": "user-charlie-1", "replyTo": { "id": 101, "name": "Bob", "snippet": "Hi Alice" } }

+ },

+ {

+ "server_message": { "id": 103, "created_at": 1700000003 },

+ "decrypted_payload": { "name": "Dana", "text": "Good to be here", "ts": 1700000003000, "uid": "user-dana-1", "replyTo": { "id": 100, "name": "Alice", "snippet": "Hello everyone" } }

+ }

+ ],

+ "expected_threads": {

+ "roots": { "101": 100, "102": 100, "103": 100 },

+ "reply_counts": { "100": 3 },

+ "first_reply": { "100": 101 }

+ },

+ "expected_reply_target": {

+ "note": "Replying to ANY message in the thread (here the legacy chain reply 102) stages the root's id with a fresh snapshot of the root's name/text.",

+ "for_message": 102,

+ "replyTo": { "id": 100, "name": "Alice", "snippet": "Hello everyone" }

+ }

+ },

{

"name": "action_line",

"description": "A /me-style action line (e.g., 'added milk' from a to-do app).",

diff --git a/web/static/apps/chat.js b/web/static/apps/chat.js

index 121b1ab..9897a50 100644

--- a/web/static/apps/chat.js

+++ b/web/static/apps/chat.js

@@ -290,10 +290,51 @@ function dayLabel(ms) {

// reactions and the reply tally — and a change to it patches only those rows in

// place (see patchBubble), never rebuilding, so a decrypted photo's <img> and a

// playing YouTube embed survive a reaction or an incoming reply landing on it.

+// rootRef walks a reply pointer to its thread's TOP message: new replies point

+// straight at the root, so this is one hop; legacy chains (a reply quoting

+// another reply) are chased through the loaded window. Returns the deepest ref

+// reachable — its .id is the root's sid when the chain resolves, or the last

+// known pointer when the parent scrolled out of the loaded window. Hop-capped

+// so a hostile payload can't cycle forever.

+function rootRef(bySid, reply) {

+ let ref = reply;

+ for (let hops = 0; hops < 100; hops++) {

+ const parent = bySid.get(ref.id);

+ if (!parent || !parent.reply || !parent.reply.id) return ref;

+ ref = parent.reply;

+ }

+ return ref;

+// replyTarget: the replyTo a reply to `m` should carry. Replying to any message

+// in a thread continues that thread, so the ref always names the thread's TOP

+// message — never the tapped reply. When the root is loaded, its name/snippet

+// are snapshotted fresh; an unloaded root falls back to the deepest quoted ref

+// we can see. Pure and exported for tests (mirrored natively by

+// ChatFeedModel.replyTarget — pinned by the reply_thread_grouping vector).

+export function replyTarget(msgs, m) {

+ if (!m.reply || !m.reply.id) return { id: m.sid, name: m.name, snippet: replySnippet(m.raw) };

+ const bySid = new Map(msgs.map((x) => [x.sid, x]));

+ const ref = rootRef(bySid, m.reply);

+ const root = bySid.get(ref.id);

+ return root

+ ? { id: root.sid, name: root.name, snippet: replySnippet(root.raw) }

+ : { id: ref.id || 0, name: ref.name || "", snippet: ref.snippet || "" };

export function viewItems(msgs) {

- const replyCounts = new Map(); // parent sid → replies

+ // Reply threads group on the resolved ROOT message: every reply tallies on

+ // its thread's top message (legacy chains resolve transitively), and each

+ // reply carries its root sid (`replyRoot`) so taps/jumps land on the thread.

+ const bySid = new Map(msgs.map((m) => [m.sid, m]));

+ const replyCounts = new Map(); // thread root sid → messages in its thread

+ const roots = new Map(); // reply sid → its thread's root sid

for (const m of msgs) {

- if (m.reply && m.reply.id) replyCounts.set(m.reply.id, (replyCounts.get(m.reply.id) || 0) + 1);

+ if (m.reply && m.reply.id) {

+ const root = rootRef(bySid, m.reply).id;

+ roots.set(m.sid, root);

+ replyCounts.set(root, (replyCounts.get(root) || 0) + 1);

+ }

}

const out = [];

let prev = null;

@@ -315,6 +356,7 @@ export function viewItems(msgs) {

timeSep,

cont,

replyCount,

+ replyRoot: roots.get(m.sid) || 0,

vrev: `${m.rev}|${timeSep ? (timeSep.withDay ? "D" : "t") : ""}|${cont ? 1 : 0}`,

srev: `${reactSig}|${replyCount}`,

});

@@ -687,7 +729,9 @@ function renderItem(m, ctx) {

wrap.dataset.id = m.sid; // lets a reply quote scroll back to this message

wrap.dataset.t = m.ts;

wrap.dataset.sender = m.name;

- if (m.reply && m.reply.id) wrap.dataset.replyTo = m.reply.id;

+ // Tag with the resolved thread root (not the quoted id) so the "N Replies"

+ // jump on the root finds legacy chain replies too.

+ if (m.reply && m.reply.id) wrap.dataset.replyTo = m.replyRoot || m.reply.id;

if (!mine && m.name && host && host.isGroup && host.isGroup(ctx.threadId) && !m.cont) {

const nm = document.createElement("div");

@@ -2511,7 +2555,8 @@ function buildSkeleton(el, ctx) {

refreshSend,

startReply(m) {

editing = null;

- replyTo = { id: m.sid, name: m.name, snippet: replySnippet(m.raw) };

+ // Replying to a reply continues its thread: target the TOP message.

+ replyTo = replyTarget(((ctx.getState() || {}).msgs) || [], m);

refreshBanners();

// Embedded: the native shell draws the reply banner and focuses its own

// composer (this one is hidden).