| 1 | { |
| 2 | "Slug": "spinel", |
| 3 | "Language": "Spinel", |
| 4 | "Status": "LIVE", |
| 5 | "URL": "https://todo-spinel-4.bfj.oncarlos.com", |
| 6 | "Version": "e344882", |
| 7 | "Stack": "", |
| 8 | "Source": "https://amadan.net/carlos/todomvc-bakeoff?ref=main\u0026path=apps/spinel", |
| 9 | "BehaviourJSOn": { |
| 10 | "Passed": 35, |
| 11 | "Failed": 0, |
| 12 | "Skipped": 0 |
| 13 | }, |
| 14 | "BehaviourJSOff": { |
| 15 | "Passed": 32, |
| 16 | "Failed": 0, |
| 17 | "Skipped": 3 |
| 18 | }, |
| 19 | "TTFBEmpty": { |
| 20 | "N": 30, |
| 21 | "P50": 94.565, |
| 22 | "P95": 101.677, |
| 23 | "P99": 105.118, |
| 24 | "Min": 84.654, |
| 25 | "Max": 105.118 |
| 26 | }, |
| 27 | "TTFB50": { |
| 28 | "N": 30, |
| 29 | "P50": 92.83, |
| 30 | "P95": 103.283, |
| 31 | "P99": 108.763, |
| 32 | "Min": 82.851, |
| 33 | "Max": 108.763 |
| 34 | }, |
| 35 | "Wake": [ |
| 36 | 1248.33, |
| 37 | 1353.544, |
| 38 | 1285.352 |
| 39 | ], |
| 40 | "Load": [ |
| 41 | { |
| 42 | "Scenario": "read", |
| 43 | "Concurrency": 1, |
| 44 | "RPS": 25.594970301672053, |
| 45 | "P50Ms": 38.742631, |
| 46 | "P95Ms": 42.993732, |
| 47 | "P99Ms": 46.257200999999995, |
| 48 | "ErrorRate": 0, |
| 49 | "Status": { |
| 50 | "200": 255 |
| 51 | } |
| 52 | }, |
| 53 | { |
| 54 | "Scenario": "read", |
| 55 | "Concurrency": 2, |
| 56 | "RPS": 54.99317071708903, |
| 57 | "P50Ms": 35.90533, |
| 58 | "P95Ms": 41.97235, |
| 59 | "P99Ms": 62.428013, |
| 60 | "ErrorRate": 0, |
| 61 | "Status": { |
| 62 | "200": 548 |
| 63 | } |
| 64 | }, |
| 65 | { |
| 66 | "Scenario": "read", |
| 67 | "Concurrency": 4, |
| 68 | "RPS": 247.9686645966048, |
| 69 | "P50Ms": 15.490781, |
| 70 | "P95Ms": 21.757472, |
| 71 | "P99Ms": 29.339324, |
| 72 | "ErrorRate": 0, |
| 73 | "Status": { |
| 74 | "200": 2476 |
| 75 | } |
| 76 | }, |
| 77 | { |
| 78 | "Scenario": "read", |
| 79 | "Concurrency": 8, |
| 80 | "RPS": 445.1923600556087, |
| 81 | "P50Ms": 16.816647, |
| 82 | "P95Ms": 26.753986, |
| 83 | "P99Ms": 36.077849, |
| 84 | "ErrorRate": 0, |
| 85 | "Status": { |
| 86 | "200": 4445 |
| 87 | } |
| 88 | }, |
| 89 | { |
| 90 | "Scenario": "read", |
| 91 | "Concurrency": 16, |
| 92 | "RPS": 656.0083460563341, |
| 93 | "P50Ms": 20.694995000000002, |
| 94 | "P95Ms": 41.204227, |
| 95 | "P99Ms": 64.351545, |
| 96 | "ErrorRate": 0, |
| 97 | "Status": { |
| 98 | "200": 6545 |
| 99 | } |
| 100 | }, |
| 101 | { |
| 102 | "Scenario": "read", |
| 103 | "Concurrency": 32, |
| 104 | "RPS": 627.8284193984191, |
| 105 | "P50Ms": 45.189996, |
| 106 | "P95Ms": 77.537528, |
| 107 | "P99Ms": 170.328653, |
| 108 | "ErrorRate": 0, |
| 109 | "Status": { |
| 110 | "200": 6247 |
| 111 | } |
| 112 | }, |
| 113 | { |
| 114 | "Scenario": "read", |
| 115 | "Concurrency": 64, |
| 116 | "RPS": 721.7061662902305, |
| 117 | "P50Ms": 82.34214700000001, |
| 118 | "P95Ms": 128.715374, |
| 119 | "P99Ms": 230.934482, |
| 120 | "ErrorRate": 0, |
| 121 | "Status": { |
| 122 | "200": 7154 |
| 123 | } |
| 124 | }, |
| 125 | { |
| 126 | "Scenario": "read", |
| 127 | "Concurrency": 128, |
| 128 | "RPS": 2990.4632740577986, |
| 129 | "P50Ms": 21.819719000000003, |
| 130 | "P95Ms": 128.803908, |
| 131 | "P99Ms": 177.15046, |
| 132 | "ErrorRate": 0.8045324827933523, |
| 133 | "Status": { |
| 134 | "200": 5822, |
| 135 | "503": 23963 |
| 136 | } |
| 137 | }, |
| 138 | { |
| 139 | "Scenario": "toggle", |
| 140 | "Concurrency": 1, |
| 141 | "RPS": 83.88447238019424, |
| 142 | "P50Ms": 9.788593, |
| 143 | "P95Ms": 15.403773000000001, |
| 144 | "P99Ms": 21.303023, |
| 145 | "ErrorRate": 0, |
| 146 | "Status": { |
| 147 | "303": 838 |
| 148 | } |
| 149 | }, |
| 150 | { |
| 151 | "Scenario": "toggle", |
| 152 | "Concurrency": 2, |
| 153 | "RPS": 179.67660671670595, |
| 154 | "P50Ms": 10.722333, |
| 155 | "P95Ms": 15.036688, |
| 156 | "P99Ms": 17.771734000000002, |
| 157 | "ErrorRate": 0, |
| 158 | "Status": { |
| 159 | "303": 1795 |
| 160 | } |
| 161 | }, |
| 162 | { |
| 163 | "Scenario": "toggle", |
| 164 | "Concurrency": 4, |
| 165 | "RPS": 310.1625328622903, |
| 166 | "P50Ms": 12.498603000000001, |
| 167 | "P95Ms": 17.47861, |
| 168 | "P99Ms": 23.312796, |
| 169 | "ErrorRate": 0, |
| 170 | "Status": { |
| 171 | "303": 3098 |
| 172 | } |
| 173 | }, |
| 174 | { |
| 175 | "Scenario": "toggle", |
| 176 | "Concurrency": 8, |
| 177 | "RPS": 556.9101887089065, |
| 178 | "P50Ms": 14.2856, |
| 179 | "P95Ms": 18.779223, |
| 180 | "P99Ms": 23.257653, |
| 181 | "ErrorRate": 0, |
| 182 | "Status": { |
| 183 | "303": 5562 |
| 184 | } |
| 185 | }, |
| 186 | { |
| 187 | "Scenario": "toggle", |
| 188 | "Concurrency": 16, |
| 189 | "RPS": 3.299356197285095, |
| 190 | "P50Ms": 1399.654903, |
| 191 | "P95Ms": 1403.356961, |
| 192 | "P99Ms": 1403.356961, |
| 193 | "ErrorRate": 0, |
| 194 | "Status": { |
| 195 | "303": 17 |
| 196 | } |
| 197 | }, |
| 198 | { |
| 199 | "Scenario": "toggle", |
| 200 | "Concurrency": 32, |
| 201 | "RPS": 1532.8835689908904, |
| 202 | "P50Ms": 15.445893, |
| 203 | "P95Ms": 31.467546, |
| 204 | "P99Ms": 52.586470000000006, |
| 205 | "ErrorRate": 0, |
| 206 | "Status": { |
| 207 | "303": 15300 |
| 208 | } |
| 209 | }, |
| 210 | { |
| 211 | "Scenario": "toggle", |
| 212 | "Concurrency": 64, |
| 213 | "RPS": 2282.5118850616304, |
| 214 | "P50Ms": 20.323867, |
| 215 | "P95Ms": 47.209343000000004, |
| 216 | "P99Ms": 71.43903999999999, |
| 217 | "ErrorRate": 0, |
| 218 | "Status": { |
| 219 | "303": 22766 |
| 220 | } |
| 221 | }, |
| 222 | { |
| 223 | "Scenario": "toggle", |
| 224 | "Concurrency": 128, |
| 225 | "RPS": 2451.4011261368464, |
| 226 | "P50Ms": 38.70759, |
| 227 | "P95Ms": 92.036958, |
| 228 | "P99Ms": 161.91760299999999, |
| 229 | "ErrorRate": 0, |
| 230 | "Status": { |
| 231 | "303": 24392 |
| 232 | } |
| 233 | }, |
| 234 | { |
| 235 | "Scenario": "toggle", |
| 236 | "Concurrency": 256, |
| 237 | "RPS": 2892.398792397893, |
| 238 | "P50Ms": 74.994662, |
| 239 | "P95Ms": 152.24756, |
| 240 | "P99Ms": 246.057975, |
| 241 | "ErrorRate": 0.24245065904177418, |
| 242 | "Status": { |
| 243 | "303": 21725, |
| 244 | "502": 6953 |
| 245 | } |
| 246 | }, |
| 247 | { |
| 248 | "Scenario": "read-after", |
| 249 | "Concurrency": 1, |
| 250 | "RPS": 66.49173397370429, |
| 251 | "P50Ms": 12.198212999999999, |
| 252 | "P95Ms": 17.754181, |
| 253 | "P99Ms": 22.703056, |
| 254 | "ErrorRate": 0, |
| 255 | "Status": { |
| 256 | "200": 664 |
| 257 | } |
| 258 | }, |
| 259 | { |
| 260 | "Scenario": "read-after", |
| 261 | "Concurrency": 2, |
| 262 | "RPS": 139.3728286956172, |
| 263 | "P50Ms": 13.792565, |
| 264 | "P95Ms": 19.511307, |
| 265 | "P99Ms": 24.752534, |
| 266 | "ErrorRate": 0, |
| 267 | "Status": { |
| 268 | "200": 1392 |
| 269 | } |
| 270 | }, |
| 271 | { |
| 272 | "Scenario": "read-after", |
| 273 | "Concurrency": 4, |
| 274 | "RPS": 251.77386594824677, |
| 275 | "P50Ms": 15.484064, |
| 276 | "P95Ms": 20.537094999999997, |
| 277 | "P99Ms": 26.231531999999998, |
| 278 | "ErrorRate": 0, |
| 279 | "Status": { |
| 280 | "200": 2514 |
| 281 | } |
| 282 | }, |
| 283 | { |
| 284 | "Scenario": "read-after", |
| 285 | "Concurrency": 8, |
| 286 | "RPS": 386.1619525826817, |
| 287 | "P50Ms": 16.855828, |
| 288 | "P95Ms": 26.412496, |
| 289 | "P99Ms": 38.507045, |
| 290 | "ErrorRate": 0, |
| 291 | "Status": { |
| 292 | "200": 3854 |
| 293 | } |
| 294 | }, |
| 295 | { |
| 296 | "Scenario": "read-after", |
| 297 | "Concurrency": 16, |
| 298 | "RPS": 584.8175879733568, |
| 299 | "P50Ms": 20.718797000000002, |
| 300 | "P95Ms": 44.462733, |
| 301 | "P99Ms": 63.458346999999996, |
| 302 | "ErrorRate": 0, |
| 303 | "Status": { |
| 304 | "200": 5833 |
| 305 | } |
| 306 | }, |
| 307 | { |
| 308 | "Scenario": "read-after", |
| 309 | "Concurrency": 32, |
| 310 | "RPS": 3.199286737897577, |
| 311 | "P50Ms": 0, |
| 312 | "P95Ms": 0, |
| 313 | "P99Ms": 0, |
| 314 | "ErrorRate": 0 |
| 315 | }, |
| 316 | { |
| 317 | "Scenario": "read-after", |
| 318 | "Concurrency": 64, |
| 319 | "RPS": 662.0611944347767, |
| 320 | "P50Ms": 78.303783, |
| 321 | "P95Ms": 137.770103, |
| 322 | "P99Ms": 247.53055600000002, |
| 323 | "ErrorRate": 0, |
| 324 | "Status": { |
| 325 | "200": 6558 |
| 326 | } |
| 327 | }, |
| 328 | { |
| 329 | "Scenario": "read-after", |
| 330 | "Concurrency": 128, |
| 331 | "RPS": 705.8385464581186, |
| 332 | "P50Ms": 148.717762, |
| 333 | "P95Ms": 262.54161799999997, |
| 334 | "P99Ms": 1461.214874, |
| 335 | "ErrorRate": 0, |
| 336 | "Status": { |
| 337 | "200": 6938 |
| 338 | } |
| 339 | }, |
| 340 | { |
| 341 | "Scenario": "read-after", |
| 342 | "Concurrency": 256, |
| 343 | "RPS": 888.065025131621, |
| 344 | "P50Ms": 272.531186, |
| 345 | "P95Ms": 438.97776, |
| 346 | "P99Ms": 1592.9036810000002, |
| 347 | "ErrorRate": 0.20815003473026164, |
| 348 | "Status": { |
| 349 | "200": 6840, |
| 350 | "502": 1798 |
| 351 | } |
| 352 | } |
| 353 | ], |
| 354 | "Weight": { |
| 355 | "HTMLBytes": 41526, |
| 356 | "JSBytes": 2655 |
| 357 | }, |
| 358 | "Memory": { |
| 359 | "IdleKB": 8364, |
| 360 | "PeakKB": 13096, |
| 361 | "AfterKB": 12132 |
| 362 | }, |
| 363 | "Code": { |
| 364 | "Server": 495, |
| 365 | "Templates": 0, |
| 366 | "JS": 71, |
| 367 | "Tests": 0, |
| 368 | "Deps": 2 |
| 369 | }, |
| 370 | "Build": { |
| 371 | "ColdSeconds": 287.12381672, |
| 372 | "WarmSeconds": 101.340795406, |
| 373 | "EditSeconds": 103.978456017, |
| 374 | "Bytes": 8749592, |
| 375 | "Host": "DOCS-T1", |
| 376 | "ColdRuns": 1, |
| 377 | "Runs": 3 |
| 378 | }, |
| 379 | "TokensBuild": { |
| 380 | "Input": 258, |
| 381 | "Output": 99309, |
| 382 | "CacheRead": 22408692, |
| 383 | "CacheWrite": 276287, |
| 384 | "Turns": 132, |
| 385 | "Seconds": 4631.851, |
| 386 | "CostUSD": 8.679246399999998 |
| 387 | }, |
| 388 | "TokensFix": { |
| 389 | "Input": 44, |
| 390 | "Output": 20701, |
| 391 | "CacheRead": 6777148, |
| 392 | "CacheWrite": 31920, |
| 393 | "Turns": 22, |
| 394 | "Seconds": 565.253, |
| 395 | "CostUSD": 2.0249855999999955 |
| 396 | }, |
| 397 | "TokensSecurity": { |
| 398 | "Input": 0, |
| 399 | "Output": 0, |
| 400 | "CacheRead": 0, |
| 401 | "CacheWrite": 0, |
| 402 | "Turns": 0, |
| 403 | "Seconds": 0, |
| 404 | "CostUSD": 0 |
| 405 | }, |
| 406 | "TokensReview": { |
| 407 | "Input": 916819, |
| 408 | "Output": 4711, |
| 409 | "CacheRead": 797824, |
| 410 | "CacheWrite": 0, |
| 411 | "Turns": 2, |
| 412 | "Seconds": 0, |
| 413 | "CostUSD": 0 |
| 414 | }, |
| 415 | "Readability": { |
| 416 | "Naming": 4, |
| 417 | "Structure": 4, |
| 418 | "Traceability": 5, |
| 419 | "Errors": 3, |
| 420 | "Comments": 4, |
| 421 | "Overall": 7, |
| 422 | "Notes": "Strongest: traceability. Each route reads top to bottom: origin check, visitor, path_id, todo_exists, one inline SQL statement, finish_post, render_lists. Comments explain the non-obvious (Spinel subset, single-cursor shim, token-issuance check, BUILD_NOTE). Weakest: errors. Write paths (run_sql, add_todo, rename_todo, record_token) discard DB.step's result, so a failed INSERT or UPDATE silently returns a stale fragment; the JS catch-all reload hides failures too. Lesser points: parallel arrays with a `done` field of ints, generic run_sql with a magic `id \u003e 0` bind rule, layout/page/path_id filed under the Actions divider, and unexplained constants (18 and 19 character limits)." |
| 423 | }, |
| 424 | "ReviewFindings": [ |
| 425 | "[correctness] `apps/spinel/app.rb:475` and `:527` — `strip` only removes ASCII whitespace. A title containing only U+00A0 or U+2003 creates a blank-looking todo, and editing to that value does not delete it. Apply Unicode whitespace trimming before the empty-title check.", |
| 426 | "[correctness] `apps/spinel/patches/2-tep-bakeoff.patch:330` — URL decoding turns `%00` into a NUL inside a C string, which is then truncated when copied into Ruby. Posting `title=before%00after` silently stores `before`; editing with `title=%00after` deletes the todo. Preserve decoded string lengths so input cannot silently become a different title or action.", |
| 427 | "[spec] `apps/spinel/Makefile:130` — `clean-deps` deletes only the local SQLite and tep artifacts. The arm64 build still links precompiled OpenSSL, zlib and zstd libraries from the shared toolchain root (`scripts/arm64-cc:21`), so the next build does not compile every third-party library from scratch as required. Build those dependencies into the app’s own cache and include them in `clean-deps`." |
| 428 | ], |
| 429 | "Notes": [ |
| 430 | "Its server process exited (status 0) 16 times during the load test, and Carloku restarted it each time; the edge answered 502 in between." |
| 431 | ] |
| 432 | } |
| 433 | |
amadan