carlos / platform Public

| Prior finding | Disposition | Answer in rev 5.4 | |---|---|---| | B4-1 — Volume recording gates runtime admission | Resolved | §8 explicitly excludes volume recording from startup, row minting, relocation and recovery. Recorder failure alerts and leaves local chores open. §10 specifies startup and recovery coverage with the record prefix unwritable; §19 removes the plan’s volume gate. | | B4-2 — Summaries retain disk-dependent fencing | Resolved | §5.8 conditions chore discharge on qualifying volume records. §6 separates delete_on_termination from execution fencing. §7’s one-box recovery establishes the fence from the terminated observation alone. |

New findings: none. No new P1, P2 or P3 issue found within the brief’s scope. Previously resolved findings and surviving-disk retention remain closed under the stated rulings.

Reviewed spec c6c43da7 against claim 98b45332, moves a4711728 and code at origin/main 09814f7f, including plan 1a. The requested claim and moves amendments remain explicit dependencies; this verdict does not imply they are already implemented.

No files changed or tests run; this was a source and contract review.

Verdict: ready for plan.