carlos / platform Public

Reviewed f4614a392dd01b9b5fc6ea46c3d106e38a8011d5 read-only. No builds or tests run; working tree unchanged.

Round-5 item — Closed. The revised contract withdraws the commit ceiling and explicitly accepts later commits. The conditional-write citations match the code. TestAWriteTheConsoleGaveUpOnCanCommitLater delays the mutation itself until after cancellation and a subsequent fresh refusal. Both filesystem authority rows are marked ruled.

New finding — P3: The SDK test misses successful writes through the wrapper stack. At Task 4, line 3203, the fake returns not-found, so the roster write with ETag "e0" exits at the boundary’s CAS check. The assertion expects only a GET; the successful PUT below bypasses both wrappers. Consequently, dropping the context specifically when either wrapper forwards Put would escape this test. Add successful conditional writes through the complete stack and assert the outgoing PUT deadline. The current forwarding code preserves the context, so this is a coverage gap, not a demonstrated runtime defect.

The inherited stop/start verification remains partly complete, explicitly gated before activation.

---

FIRST PROMPT: Round 6 review of region HA 2b at f4614a39.

WHAT: Check round-5 closure and identify new findings.

STATUS: Round-5 P2 closed; one new P3; no P2-or-higher findings.

NEEDED: Nothing for this review.

RECOMMENDED: Build the plan; strengthen the SDK write-path test during implementation.

SESSION: Safe to close. No files changed or background processes started.

Verdict: ready to build.