All three round-2 findings are **closed in the proposed code**:
4
5
- **Tasks 11–12:** Capacity checks precede the placement gates, with full HTTP move tests for missing edges files and blank addresses.
6
- **Task 11:** Selection precedes environment binding. Tests check unchanged store bytes, no writes on refusal, and reuse of the selected executor.
7
- **Task 13:** The metric destination comes from the signed roster, with conflicting edges-file tests.
8
9
Platform-1e’s rev-2 conditions, as reproduced in the plan, are met on static inspection: selection writes nothing and takes no lease; the move check only refuses; record-write sites remain unchanged. Census values still require recomputation on the build base.
10
11
I could not access amadan #236. Acceptance of the new `chooseCreateFirst` census unit remains the separate dependency documented under [Open questions](/home/paulca/amadan.net/carlos/platform/.claude/worktrees/design-region-ha-two-box/docs/superpowers/plans/2026-10-16-region-ha-2a-core.md:6933). This review does not supply that acceptance.
12
13
---
14
15
**FIRST PROMPT:**
16
Review plan 2a round 3 at `5d2e7169`, read-only, without heavy checks.
17
18
**WHAT:**
19
Check prior findings, ruling conditions and new defects.
20
21
**STATUS:**
22
Three findings closed; no new findings. No builds or tests run.
23
24
**NEEDED:**
25
Nothing further for this review.
26
27
**RECOMMENDED:**
28
Proceed through the plan’s existing copy and census gates.
29
30
**SESSION:**
31
Safe to close. Worktree unchanged; no processes started.
amadan