carlos / platform Public

Finding 1 remains the only open finding in this review. Reviewed model 372f7a4b against built HEAD 0d5a1f46 (code change 6a4eadde). No new P1/P2/P3 finding established.

P2 — Rollback still loses source files protection. At movessources.go:491, restoring returns the newest admission’s region. After target admission, source-region parks can therefore lose protection for files needed by rollback. This remains a latent retirement defect; destructive production execution was not established.

The requested judgments:

• Item 1: closed. The model’s first serving wake now takes a fresh generation and installation stamp, records the stopped probe’s writes_lost, and subsequently retires P. The N6 witness checks these at regionhacompletionwitness_test.go:212.
• Item 2: closed. Session launches close before the flush; the admission fence follows the recorded positions. The model’s admission guard and restart witness cover the intervening interval at regionhacompletionwitness_test.go:346.
• Ruling 87: sound on the inspected paths. flushStopped:201 orders writers → database → files → durable record. Any failure prevents the subsequent stop. A matching recorded flush permits retry without the former replicator.
• Deadline and restart: EndProbe:479 bounds the flush using the worker’s deadline calculation. Before a record exists, a restarted agent lacks the attempt required by writersStopped:216; it refuses rather than completing over unflushed writes. The worker:518 then marks the operation stuck.
• Amended ruling 75: sound. After flushing, a foreign fence causes refusal before Wake.Stop at relocationowners.go:305. The foreign fence remains intact. “Without asking root” means without requesting root’s stop; the earlier writers-stopped observation still contacts root.

Both targeted test commands failed before execution because Go could not create its build directory on the read-only filesystem.

Verdict: yes—once finding 1 is fixed and the required gates pass, relocation may merge dormant. This is a static review verdict, not activation approval or a claim that tests passed.

---

FIRST PROMPT: Follow the L18 joint-round review brief against the model and built HEADs.

WHAT: Determine whether finding 1 is the only remaining dormant-merge blocker.

STATUS: Review complete; one existing P2 remains. Tests could not run.

NEEDED: Nothing for this review.

RECOMMENDED: Fix source protection and rerun the joint gate before merging dormant.

SESSION: Safe to close; no files changed or background processes started.