amadan
carlos / platform Public
Reviewed 56572359.
| Round 11 finding | Disposition | Assessment against rev 12 | |---|---|---| | Admission trimming loses valid file origins | Resolved | Referenced origins now survive independently of admissions. The regression exercises ten real admission/publication cycles and successfully copies the retained g1 file. |
- P2 — Task 7: acknowledging a successor before sweeping its predecessor can deadlock.
Acknowledge, lines 8998–9011 looks up controllers by host and operation, then opens a missing controller using e.Lifetime.
If relocation A completes and B starts before this box sweeps A, A still holds the host’s lifetime lock. B’s hostexec.Open waits for that lock; its pass deadline cannot interrupt the agent-lifetime context. The sequential participant pass cannot reach the sweep that would release A.
Fix: retire obsolete controllers for the same host before opening a successor, with bounded acquisition. Handle ClearStale’s refusal when the successor still lists this box (controller.go:643). Add a real-controller regression where B starts before A’s sweep. This is an additional interleaving in the cleanup added after round 2.
- P2 — Task 8c, Step 4 / Stage B contracts: successful probes require an unassigned launch dependency.
R1 requests probe dispatch; Task 8c’s gate requires 6b and that dispatch.
However, upstream claim Plan 6b explicitly supports no enabled tenant launch. Its Roles.Preflight refuses before probe dispatch (6b:12587–12590, 14392). Its external-completion gate requires a reservation-bearing isolated root-launch protocol and states that external owner adapters do not supply it (6b:15881). Completing R1 as specified still leaves every production probe refused.
Fix: assign that integration through an explicit upstream request and Stage B activation gate. Add a named production probe test covering successful isolated launch and refusal without the protocol.
I accept rulings 1–24. All 12 embedded patches pass git apply --check; all 41 complete Go blocks parse with gofmt. Compilation and tests were not reproduced in this read-only session.
---
FIRST PROMPT: “Follow the review brief docs/superpowers/plans/CODEX-PLAN-REGION-HA-1BN-BRIEF-12.md. Review the plan at commit 56572359.”
WHAT: Review Stage A readiness and Stage B contracts.
STATUS: Round 11 resolved; two P2 findings.
NEEDED: Nothing.
RECOMMENDED: Fix successor controller handover and explicitly gate the production launcher.
SESSION: Safe to close — no files changed or processes left running.
Verdict: not ready.