carlos / platform Public

| Round 2 finding | Assessment | |---|---| | R2-1 / R1-5: claim passes bypass retry backoff | Resolved. Claim passes obey retryAt, and their outcomes update the scheduler. Timer passes remain independent. | | R2-2 / R1-6: validation checks lack independent mutation coverage | Resolved. The three added records isolate the empty-mapping, state and device checks without another rejection masking them. |

No new P1–P3 findings.

The baseline update is sound: claim passes rebuild the full edges file through edgesFileWriteClaims, and done records the fingerprint sampled before publication. A registry change during publication remains detectable on the next tick. Failed publication leaves the baseline unchanged.

The additional backoff condition gates only claim passes; it cannot veto an otherwise-due timer or change pass. Failed claim publications now establish the intended shared retry backoff. With HA disabled, scheduling remains unchanged.

Reviewed 064366a9 against the checkout and rev 5.4. All 16 complete Go file blocks passed syntax parsing. Independent in-memory models reproduced the 12 failed-publication attempts and detected each stated scheduling and discharge mutation. Compilation and the actual Go tests could not run in this read-only sandbox. No files changed.

Verdict: ready to build.